Aurelia VS AngularJS 2.0
Angular
I spend a couple of hours familiarizing myself with angular 2 for a pluralsight audition which resulted in the following screencast.
Aurelia
I then got an interesting comment that aurelia is the client side app framework to use. I try to be agnostic about the frameworks, libs and the tools that I use, so spent a couple of hours familiarizing myself with aurelia as well which resulted in the following screencast where I port the angular app in a matter of minutes.
Conclussions
Angular is at the time I’m writing this post in alpha and it’s changing a lot, which is really frustrating since something always seems to be broken and documentation/examples are inaccurate even on their own site. It’s hard to keep track of if it’s *for, *ngfor, *ng-for or something completely different from one build to the other.
I like that web components are the mainstay and it unifies react.js, angular.js and polymer. One big thumbs up to that $scope is gone, but also a big thumbs down for that two-way data-bindings is gone. Kind of a deal breaker for me. Angular has teamed up with the typescript team and they are pushing it which definitely is a good thing but not angular specific ergo no credit for that.
Learning curve was about the same for both frameworks, both are using the ES6 module loading system and depending on runtime transpilation to ES5 for now. What tips the scale towards Aurelia for me is that it’s cleaner, supports two-way data-bindings and that it’s all about conventions over configuration/code. That’s my opinion after a first look at both frameworks, watch the screencasts and judge for yourself.
As I mentioned I try to stay agnostic about the frameworks, libs and tools that I use, but I’ll definitely give aurelia a try for my next web project and try to forget that there is an IDE named VS Code out there. *BOOM* ;-)
EDIT: About 2-way data binding
It’s ridiculous how many emails I’ve received about this, but really, there is no 2-way data binding in angular 2. Do not confuse the square-bracket-parenthesis-syntax [(ng-model)] with two-way bindings — it one-way binds to the property with square brackets and listens for events with parenthesis. They obviously realized that typing
is cumbersome so they introduced a new directive called ng-model
So now you have very angular specific code in your view templates instead of just two-way binding to the DOM property. I refactor the code to bind to the checked property from this screencast in the beginning of next one here.
I like angular
Don’t get me wrong, I like angular and I will use angular 2, but I don’t mindlessly love everything they do like some fan boy. Stay open minded people and don’t be afraid to express your opinion, it’s just yet another framework. You don’t need to love everything the angular team produces.
By the way, make sure to check out my latest screencast on angular 2 forms!
Until next time, have a nice day!
Source code as always at @ https://github.com/ajtowf
Links: aurelia.io angular.io
Keywords : Visual Studio Code, HTML5, JavaScript, AngularJS 2.0, Aurelia, TypeScript
